The New York Giants appear increasingly likely to hand J.J. McCarthy their starting quarterback job after his impressive performance against the New Orleans Saints. The young quarterback provided a spark in Sunday’s loss, strengthening his case to replace Jameis Winston as the team’s primary option.
According to a report shared by Evan Sidery, the Saints could give McCarthy another week to prepare before making him the full-time starter by Halloween. McCarthy’s opportunity comes after the Giants acquired him from the Minnesota Vikings in September. With Jaxson Dart sidelined for the remainder of the season, the former first-round pick now has a chance to establish himself with the Giants.
J.J. McCarthy Strengthens His Case After Giants’ Loss
The Giants’ 34-27 defeat to the Saints offered an important glimpse of what McCarthy could bring to their offense. Entering the game in the fourth quarter, he helped New York mount a comeback after the team fell behind by 24 points. McCarthy threw for 243 yards during his brief appearance, giving the Giants renewed momentum late in the contest. Although the Giants ultimately fell short, his performance raised fresh questions about whether Winston should retain the starting position.
The Giants might give McCarthy one more week to prepare behind Jameis Winston before becoming the full-time starter by Halloween.
The Giants are planning to soon move forward with JJ McCarthy as their QB1, per @RapSheet.
New York might give McCarthy one more week to prepare behind Jameis Winston before becoming the full-time starter by Halloween. pic.twitter.com/8vUYObAfyM
— Evan Sidery (@esidery) October 19, 2026
Meanwhile, head coach John Harbaugh has not yet confirmed who will start the Giants’ next game. Following the loss, he said the decision was too early to make immediately after the contest. That leaves Winston’s position uncertain despite his experience and previous opportunities to lead the offense.
McCarthy still faces the challenge of learning a new system after joining the Giants from the Vikings. Adjusting to the playbook, offensive personnel, and coaching expectations will be important as the Giants evaluate his readiness.
However, his performance against the Saints gives the coaching staff a compelling reason to consider the change. Similarly, his ability to move the offense during the fourth quarter offered a different dimension when the team needed an urgent response.
Besides McCarthy’s undeniable abilities, Winston’s struggles have increased the pressure on the Giants to reconsider their options. His two interceptions against the Saints contributed to the decision to replace him during the game. The Giants must now weigh McCarthy’s potential against the risks of promoting a quarterback still learning the offense.
A strong relief appearance can create momentum, but maintaining that level across an entire game presents a different challenge. That said, the coming week could prove decisive for McCarthy.
More preparation would give him additional time to understand the offense and build chemistry with his teammates. For now, Harbaugh’s decision remains unconfirmed. Yet, the Giants’ fans can rejoice in the hope that McCarthy has handed them a genuine alternative at quarterback, with a recent performance that could accelerate his path to the starting role.
Related reading:
NFL Fans Label Eagles ‘Criminals’ After Jalen Hurts Is Done for 2026 Season
Former Cowboys Starting Quarterback Released – Breaking News
Saints HC Kellen Moore Provides Injury Updates on Kaden Elliss, Jordyn Tyson, and Cesar Ruiz
How Has Milton Williams Helped the Patriots’ Defense Over the Last Three Weeks?
The post Giants Plan to Make J.J. McCarthy Their QB1 as Starting Role Nears, per Report appeared first on Gridiron Heroics.