If you want a litmus test for how low MAGA is willing to sink, it’s right there in the Ohio Governor's race.
Earlier this week, Ohio gubernatorial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy released an attack ad featuring a woman named Donna Arthur, the estranged mother of his opponent, the physician and researcher Amy Acton. Almost instantly, the spot kicked off a firestorm of condemnation and debate that has fractured the Republican coalition on the eve of a hugely consequential midterm election.
In the ad, Arthur alleges that her daughter, Acton, is a “liar.” “It’s not easy for a mother to say this, but Amy has a serious problem,” Arthur says. The ad — a direct family member denouncing a candidate — is the kind of political hit that is often devastating to a campaign or a candidate’s character, which is clearly what Ramaswamy intended it to be. But the tragic and well-documented facts of Acton’s life quickly revealed Ramaswamy’s tactics as a new low for his campaign and party. Acton, 60, has been open about her traumatic early life: she allegedly suffered horrific sexual abuse by her mother’s husband, who was arrested and charged with raping her in 1978. Acton’s mother, Arthur, supported her husband in court and stayed with him until his death in 2004.
Inside the Republican party, response to the ad has become a litmus test for how deep into the post-truth nihilism of the MAGA movement someone wants to sink, with everyone involved playing a predictable role.
The lines were drawn almost immediately. The Ramaswamy campaign doubled down, saying that it would spend $4 million to promote the ad on TV. On Friday, Donald Trump engaged in a heated back-and-forth with an NBC reporter over the ad, repeatedly defending Ramaswamy’s decision to use the material.
“Look … a mother is saying, ‘Don’t put my daughter there because she’s a terrible person and she’s a liar,’” Trump said. “Why shouldn’t somebody use that?”
When the NBC reporter pushed back, mentioning the abuse allegations, Trump went on an extended diatribe, insisting: “I don’t know anything about stepfathers.”
Editor’s picks
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) October 23, 2026YIKES 😳 Trump snaps at a reporter asking him about why he's dismissing sexual abuse allegations 👇
WOMAN REPORTER: Do the sexual abuse allegations mean nothing to you, sir?
TRUMP: Wait. Wait! Wait wait wait. Slow down. Who are you with?
REPORTER: NBC, sir. But they are very… pic.twitter.com/nW0oxg3Srb
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) October 23, 2026Q: Now that you know the backstory about Amy Acton and her stepfather and why she hasn't talked to her mom in so long — her stepfather was indicted for rape — do you change your mind about the ad?
TRUMP: No. No. It's a mother speaking badly against Amy Acton. You don't know… pic.twitter.com/5AfsCUvpLs
Trump’s support for the ad puts him directly at odds with several Ohio Republicans, who have decided that Ramaswamy’s cynical play is a step too far. Current Governor Mike DeWine called the ad “deeply, deeply troubling,” for which the president promptly called him a “RINO,” or Republican in Name Only. Senator Jon Husted, whose ass Trump cannot stop complimenting on the campaign trail, also condemned the ad, saying he “would not have run” it. Former governor John Kasich and former Senator Rob Portman all came out against the ad as well. The lone high-profile Ohioan to back the ad, of course, was Vice President J.D. Vance, who said the ad “calls it out like it is.”
It’s easy to see the ad as a flashpoint in the growing war for the soul of the Grand Old Party — a “reckoning,” as one long-time strategist put it to me earlier this month. In The New York Times, opinion columnist Michelle Goldberg wrote that “denouncing the Ramaswamy ad gives conservatives a chance to try to drag their movement out of the Trumpist gutter.” The two sides here are Republicans who want to go back to a John McCain, Mitt Romney-esque style of polite conservatism, rolling back some of the depredations of the Trump era; and the post-civility cutthroats who see Trump’s moral nihilism as the blueprint for holding political power. “Trump has had the GOP by the balls for the past 11, 12, 13 years,” one conservative activist told me earlier this month. “Everybody’s sick of it.”
These critiques, though, miss the greater point of the political movement that led to Vivek Ramaswamy implicitly taking the side of a child abuser. The conservative project’s greatest strength is its moral flexibility. The reason Trump has “had the GOP by the balls,” as the conservative strategist described it, for well over a decade is because he won. Trumpism, and the brand of politics it inspires, has been enormously successful. The moderates who were uncomfortable with it have almost unanimously fallen in line or been purged from the party. The GOP’s future is still firmly in Trump’s hands.
Trending Stories
Related Content
In that system, the Ramaswamy ad is only indefensible for one reason: it failed. Take Politico’s line: “The spot isn’t just bad taste, it’s bad politics.” Taste is immaterial. Bad politics isn’t. There’s a chance now that Ramaswamy’s overreach into barbarism hurts him politically, and the quick disavowals on the part of other candidates like Husted are only there to try to mitigate that damage.
The blow, in this case, didn’t land. But don’t think for a second that the MAGAmovement will hesitate to swing that low again.