The Cleveland Guardians need to win Monday night to keep their MLB season alive, but their pitching strategy for ALCS Game 6 immediately raised questions.
Facing elimination on the road, Cleveland opted for a bullpen game rather than trying to maximize its best available pitching option.
The decision was always risky, and the early results against the Tampa Bay Rays have only made that criticism louder.
MORE:MLB history will be made regardless of World Series outcome
Elimination games are not the time to get cute
There is a legitimate argument for bullpen games during the regular season. Teams have 162 games to work through mistakes, manage workloads, and recover from a bad pitching decision. The postseason is completely different.
When a team is facing elimination, the priority should be finding a way to survive that particular game. Cleveland knew exactly what was at stake entering Game 6, yet it chose a strategy that required several pitchers to execute nearly flawlessly.
The Guardians did have a difficult situation to navigate. Gavin Williams, their best starter during the postseason, was not available on short rest, with manager Stephen Vogt confirming that was not an option. Cleveland had also heavily used its bullpen in the previous games of the series.
Still, that is precisely why the bullpen-game strategy was so dangerous. Instead of giving the team one pitcher capable of settling into the game and working deep, Cleveland needed to string together strong performances from multiple arms.
That leaves almost no margin for error.
MORE:Every MLB team’s most recent playoff win: Which franchise has the longest drought?
Cleveland is paying for the decision early
A bullpen game does not necessarily mean a team will lose. It can work if the opening pitcher gives the offense a chance, the middle relievers dominate, and the high-leverage arms can finish the job.
The problem is that everything has to go right.
If one reliever gives up a couple of runs, the entire plan can unravel because there is no traditional starter waiting to stop the bleeding. That is especially problematic in an elimination game, when falling behind early can put enormous pressure on an offense that already struggled to score during the first two games of this series. Cleveland scored only four runs across Games 4 and 5 entering Monday night.
That is exactly what makes the early deficit so concerning.
The Guardians cannot simply expect to erase a multiple-run deficit and then ask their bullpen to dominate the final innings. They have to score enough to get back into the game while simultaneously asking a collection of relievers to navigate the most important innings of Cleveland’s season.
Meanwhile, Tampa Bay handed the ball to Freddy Peralta, who entered Game 6 with a 0.79 ERA across his previous nine appearances dating back to Aug. 26.
Cleveland needed to give itself every possible advantage.
Instead, it chose the strategy with the smallest margin for error.
In the regular season, there is always tomorrow. In the postseason, there isn’t.
And in an elimination game, the argument for putting the game in the hands of your best available pitcher becomes even stronger.
— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories with The Big Lead Newsletter —