I spent the summer showing you how I build teams. I broke down the worst pick in every round. I mapped out the RB Dead Zone, walked through Zero RB, built a cost-based plan for quarterbacks and covered the new TE Premium format. I even (tried to) put it into practice in our Yahoo “Expert” League. Then the games started, and I remembered what none of those articles could control: the players have to play.
Injuries happen. Roles shift. A sure thing turns into a committee by Week 3. Before you know it, you’re staring at a 1-5 record like me, wondering how a team that looked so good on paper landed in the basement.
So, let’s try something different. No regression models. No efficiency thresholds. Just vibes. If you’re in a hole, you don’t need the safe pickup. You need someone who could flip your season. There’ll still be some data (well, maybe a lot – it’s what I do!), but you might have to squint to see the upside. When you need wins now, a little dreaming might be exactly what you need.
Geno Smith, QB, Jets vs. Dolphins (17% Rostered)
If you’re looking for a QB this late in the week, godspeed. But you may be waiting to see how Lamar Jackson looks after another limited session on Thursday. Plus, streaming options outside of the top 12 are thin. Said another way, starting Geno Smith is, at worst, a defensible move. But, at least at first glance, there’s plenty of upside.
Omar Cooper Jr. had an outstanding (full) debut. Separated consistently vs. man coverage.
— Mike Renner (@mikerenner_) October 19, 2026
Finished w/ 6 catches for 103 yards & TD with another TD called back pic.twitter.com/ByK4TFenet
We got one full game out of Omar Cooper Jr. and he instantly jumped to the top of everyone’s waiver targets. The rookie receiver led the Jets’ pass-catchers in every relevant opportunity stat. But Cooper’s 4.42 speed was an issue for the Patriots’ defense on his 48-yard hookup for a score. Coincidentally, the Dolphins are allowing the fourth-highest explosive play rate on downfield throws. And that’s just the situation for one of Smith’s options in the passing game.
Wide receivers with a 20+% target share to face Miami have averaged 17.8 PPR PPG. That bodes well for Garrett Wilson, who’s still at 6.5 looks per game. Kenyon Sadiq’s routes and targets have oscillated each week, but the spine of the Dolphins’ defense has given up the third-most PPR PPG to TEs.
In short, if we like the pass-catchers, the QB has to get some love, too. And it’s not like Smith has played poorly. He’s ahead of C.J. Stroud, Trevor Lawrence and Patrick Mahomes in CPOE. Smith’s 0.02 EPA per dropback sits right below the league average. Along with a plus matchup, starting a Jets QB doesn’t sound too crazy.
Honorable Mention: Deshaun Watson, QB, Browns at Titans
Jonah Coleman, RB, Broncos at Cardinals (32% Rostered)
As of this writing, Jonah Coleman is still on IR. He’s practiced in full throughout the week and is eligible to return to the active roster before Sunday. And if you’re hesitant on what he can do with the ball in his hands, let’s go back to the last time we saw him on the field.
Jonah Coleman - Week 2 - every touch https://t.co/Pji0uy4df5pic.twitter.com/knU1idUk4m
— Jacob Gibbs (@jagibbs_23) September 21, 2026
J.K. Dobbins has been the lead back through six weeks. Coleman is the only other Denver RB to force a carry split (both had 10 carries in Week 2). RJ Harvey needed six weeks to earn a goal-line touch. Coleman got one in his second game. Coupled with an 11% target share, the rookie RB’s usage had the makings of a starter. Besides, it’s not like his competition has put up highlight reels since he’s been out.
(Early Downs) Adj. Yards After Contact per Att.: 43rd (Dobbins), 44th (Harvey) [out of 61 qualifiers – min. 20 carries)
Forced Missed Tackle Rate: 43rd, 61st
Let’s say you believe that if the Broncos had a better running game, Bo Nix would play better. There’d be less pressure on him. More manageable third downs. Simply put, their ground attack is the problem. And you’d be partly right.
Their problems start on first and second down. Between Dobbins and Harvey, they have 96 carries to start a series. Less than a quarter have gone for five or more yards. Accordingly, Nix has had to go an average of 7.7 yards (league average is 7.6) on third down to keep drives alive. But there are other areas Coleman could help.
Dobbins has been the preferred short-yardage option, but converted just half of his attempts. Harvey’s played more snaps on third downs, but tied for allowing the 10th-most pressures of any rusher. So not only does Coleman have the chance to be an instant upgrade over his peers, but he’ll get to do it against a Cardinals’ defense surrendering the 16th-most yards to opposing RBs.
Honorable Mention: Justice Hill, RB, Ravens vs. Bengals
Konata Mumpfield, WR, Rams at Raiders (7% Rostered)
Davante Adams is out. Puka Nacua’s check engine light is on. Terrance Ferguson needs more time to get right. I’m not worried about the Rams’ long-term outlook. But I’ve got my eyebrow raised. Regardless, they still have to get through the Raiders with one of the top pass-catchers out. Funny enough, the last time Nacua was hobbled, we saw who would step up for L.A. out of their ancillary crew.
Konata Mumpfield runs by Riley Moss for the TDpic.twitter.com/mmjiP7WwUf
— Underdog NFL (@UnderdogNFL) September 28, 2026
The good news for anyone thinking of starting Konata Mumpfield is two-fold. First, his routes and targets spiked in the absence of Matthew Stafford’s primary options. A similar situation he finds himself in this weekend. Second, half of Mumpfield’s looks came on timing routes partly indicating some level of rapport with Stafford. However, as the clip indicates, their biggest connections came when using Mumpfield’s speed. But that works in his favor, too.
Las Vegas’ secondary has given up the seventh-most yards and 11th-most catches on throws of 20 air yards or more. They ran in the bottom 12 for explosive play rate allowed, too. The Raiders’ offense (sixth in PPG) has already shown their capable of keeping their opponents on a pass-friendly script. With the scoreboard, and their win-loss record likely on their minds, Mumpfield as a WR3 in one of the highest projected games of the weekend has its merits.
Honorable Mention: Christian Kirk, WR, 49ers at Falcons
Darnell Washington, TE, Steelers at Saints (3% Rostered)
I was the “Shaq, I was unfamiliar with your game” meme after digging into the Steelers’ offense earlier this week. Their pass rate is up. Aaron Rodgers is spinning it like he’s back in the MVP race. More importantly, at least for us, he can support multiple pass-catchers.
Aaron Rodgers ➡️ Darnell Washington for a Steelers TD!
— NFL (@NFL) October 18, 2026
PITvsTB on CBS/Paramount+
Stream on @NFLPluspic.twitter.com/xrU7XHX6dB
Of course, DK Metcalf and Germie Bernard will be the weekly headliners. But, remember, Rodgers is throwing more in every situation this season. Specifically, the red zone. He’s had the 10th-most attempts when in scoring position and the fourth-most from the goal-line. That’s where Darnell Washington comes into play as Pittsburgh takes on New Orleans in Paris.
(Red Zone) Route Share (since Week 3): 71.9% (Washington), 59.4% (Freiermuth)
Target Rate: 22.2%, 14.8%
TPRR: 26.1%, 21.1%
The massive TE has become one of Rodgers’ favorite targets when close to the end zone. Pat Freiermuth’s calf injury didn’t stop him from being active, but his season-low 7% target rate paved the way for more work to the fourth-year TE. At worst, Washington’s 4.5 targets per game are enough for a viable floor in desperate situations. But if you’re swinging from the fences, Mount Washington has the potential for a ceiling to swing the week in your favor.
Honorable Mention: Literally Any Healthy Rams TE at Raiders