Just imagine you’re going about your day, taking the PATH back to your home in New Jersey after a work day in the city, and you run into Paul Anthony Kelly—in a three-piece suit.
Well, some lucky commuters lived that dream this Thursday, as the Love Story star boarded a New Jersey Transit train looking like the most dapper local.
Not so shockingly, the actor did not blend into the crowd, and it wasn’t just because of his striking jawline; he was in a full olive-green suit. The set was composed of a slouchy blazer and trousers, plus a matching vest. Proving his layering expertise, Kelly wore the vest over a white button-down, which was itself layered over a classic ribbed tank.
The autumnal hues continued with his suede chocolate shoes and mustard-yellow Alex Mill tote, which was monogrammed with his surname initials: WK. (Kelly and wife Syd Widziszewski-Kelly changed their last names after marrying, and when off screen, the actor goes by Paul Anthony Widziszewski-Kelly.)
Kelly looked so John F. Kennedy Jr.-coded in some dark sunglasses as he hung out on the train. And in a very of-the-times moment, he popped on some wired earphones to listen to music on his phone.
(He also carried a Loro Piana shopping bag, because that’s how posh he is.)
Kelly and his wife and baby daughter have their home base in Portland, Oregon, but the actor is currently in Hoboken filming The Housemaid’s Secret—a performance which will mark his feature film debut—alongside Sydney Sweeney, Kirsten Dunst, and Brittany Snow.