Why Nabisco’s 100-Calorie Pack Failed in the 2000s—And How a New Wave of Founders Finally Cracked the $1B Code

But many have forgotten one failed industry attempt: Nabisco’s 100 Calorie Pack, sold from 2004-2009 at the tail end of the low-carb dieting frenzy. This was the first industry attempt at portion control packaging for adults, not tiny packs for kids.

The concept is not dead. A new generation of 70-110 calorie, portion-controlled products has grown exponentially to form a $1B+ market segment. What did these entrepreneurs do differently that marketers can learn from? And what did Nabisco get wrong?

Why The Original 100-Calorie Packs Failed In The 2000s

Let’s journey back to 2004. It’s the peak of the low-carb dieting fad kicked off by Dr. Robert Atkins’ international bestselling book. Nabisco has just launched a sub-brand called “Nabisco 100 Cal” within all its major snack brands (except Triscuit). Many of these products scaled quickly via Nabisco’s DSD distribution network but were all eventually discontinued around 2009. 

The daily digest for entrepreneurs and business leaders

As an ethnographic researcher for the food industry at the time, I discovered why this experiment fooled so many of us. You had to explore the pantries of truly committed low-carb dieters to figure out what Nabisco missed. 

Jenny Craig proved in the 1990s that rigid calorie restriction, even without altering the food, can kick-start fat-burning weight loss. Just eat inside the box each week, and you will most likely lose weight, even without increasing exercise. How? 1200 calories per day in the standard Jenny Craig program is well below the known calorie requirements for an adult female (1,800-2200). 

Given this precedent, shrinking portions of Ritz, Oreo, or Wheat Thins into tiny packs seemed like a brilliant calorie-restrictive concept for the low-carb age, no?