This is a reset in reverse; that is not the legacy - Kpebu tells Mahama on EC appointment

The kind of appointment made by President John Dramani Mahama to the Electoral Commission (EC) is disappointing and embarrassing, Lawyer Martin Kpebu, has said.

He says appointing very partisan people to the commission weakens the independence of the EC.

"This one is a reset in reverse; that is not the legacy," he said on the Key Points on TV3 Saturday, October 17.

He added "It was like a fairy tale in the negative sense. I couldn't believe my ears; I was like What is it?

"We made all the noise against Akufo-Addo's appointment. In 2024, the NDC raised issues against the director of the EC; we were here making all the noise.

"This is a strong race to the bottom. I am not sure that after a year I will continue to support JM. This appointment doesn't look like him, the reset he promised."

Earlier, the Coalition of Domestic Election Observers (CODEO) also criticised the appointment of Ms Emelia Affi Agbenyo, a known activist of the National Democratic Congress (NDC), as Deputy Chairperson of the Electoral Commission (EC) of Ghana.

President John Dramani Mahama administered the oath of office to two newly appointed Deputy Chairpersons of the Electoral Commission (EC), charging them to execute their constitutional mandate with independence, firmness, and impartiality.

Swearing in Joseph Kwaku Asamoah and Emilia Afi Agbenyo, the President stated that neither he nor his administration should receive preferential treatment from the electoral body.

He directed the new commissioners to hold all political parties and candidates to the same standards, guided strictly by the law and the national interest.

This appointment has attracted criticism against the president.

CODEO said in a statement that concerns about Ms. Agbenyo’s appointment are not about her professional qualification or technical competence. Rather, it reflects a consistent principle of the Coalition that the independence and credibility of the Electoral Commission must be protected, and its leadership must inspire public confidence in its impartiality, regardless of which political party is in government.

Unfortunately, it said, the failure to mitigate these perceptions of bias by individual members of the Commission has severely affected citizen trust in the Commission, reaching its lowest ratings in 2024, according to the Afrobarometer.

"The repeated failure to use the Presidential appointing power to reset the politics around the appointment of members to the Commission for the good of the country is extremely disappointing and frustrating. CODEO’s Call In March 2023, President John Dramani Mahama, while in opposition, criticised the appointment of persons he described as 'known party activists' to the Electoral Commission and called for an amendment of Article 43(2) of the 1992 Constitution to require parliamentary approval of new Commissioners. He also affirmed his commitment to these reforms. CODEO considers this position relevant to the present circumstances.

"The concerns President Mahama raised in opposition about partisan associations and the safeguards for the Electoral Commission’s independence are now directly relevant to appointments made under his own administration. The principles he advocated in 2023 must be applied consistently while in government. The credibility of electoral institutions demands that the same standards be upheld regardless of which political party holds power," a statement issued by CEOD said.

Below is the full statement...

CODEO Condemns Partisan Appointments to the Electoral Commission, Calls for Immediate Reconsideration, and Demands Structural Reforms to Safeguard Electoral Independence

The Coalition of Domestic Election Observers (CODEO), comprising over 41-member organizations, expresses strong disapproval regarding the appointment and swearing-in of Ms. Emelia Affi Agbenyo as Deputy Chairperson of the Electoral Commission (EC) of Ghana on October 12, 2026. While CODEO recognizes the President's constitutional authority over appointments, public evidence of Ms. Agbenyo’s active political engagement with the National Democratic Congress (NDC) during the 2024 general election campaign directly compromises the public perception of the independence, impartiality, and institutional credibility of the Electoral Commission.

As a primary stakeholder in Ghana’s democratic process, CODEO asserts that the integrity of the Electoral Commission depends not only on the actual neutrality of its commissioners, but on the public’s absolute confidence in that neutrality. Publicly Documented Political Engagement of Ms. Emelia Affi Agbenyo In August 2024, the NDC publicly announced Ms. Emelia Affi Agbenyo among its sectoral spokespersons for the party’s 2024 election manifesto, under the governance portfolio. As part of her key achievements in her bio on LinkedIn, she confirmed her role as a spokesperson for the Governance Sector during the NDC Campaign. Ms. Agbenyo’s partisan political activities were also evident online. On 20th September 2024, she posted on her Facebook page a video featuring the then NDC presidential candidate, accompanied by the party’s campaign song, Asempa by NACEE, and the hashtags #a_democracy_to_salvage and #voteforchange2024.

On 31st October 2024, she posted a photograph of John Dramani Mahama, the then NDC presidential candidate, with the caption: “To salvage our democracy, to restore good governance, reset our nation on the path of thriving democracy.” The post included the hashtags #voteJM2024 and #voteforchange2024. Again, on 2nd December 2024, she published a post on her X account stating: “I will be voting against a government that ridiculed the pains of the people. Imposing a nuisance levy on citizens is not a thing to celebrate. Governance is no joke, citizens are not your enemies.” The post included the hashtags #salvageourdemocracy, #voteforchange2024, #VoteJohnMahama2024, and #EndTyranny.

CODEO’s Consistent Position on Electoral Commission Appointments Since the exit of Dr. Kwadwo Afari-Gyan as the founding Chair of the Electoral Commission of Ghana (EC), CODEO has consistently called for a broader consultative process in the appointment of the members of the EC beyond the dictates of Article 70 (2) of the 1992 Constitution while the country waited for meaningful constitutional reform. In 2014 and 2018, CODEO made these calls in the appointments of Ms. Charlotte Osei and later Mrs. Jean Mensah, Dr. Bossman Asare and Mr. Samuel Tetteh.

The appointing Presidents did not heed to the calls. In 2023, together with STAR-Ghana Foundation and Civic Forum Initiative (CFI), CODEO called for the resignation of Dr. Peter Appiahene over concerns about his partisan affiliation with the New Patriotic Party (NPP). The appointment of Dr. Peter Appiahene rightly generated condemnation from many groups, including the National Democratic Congress, prompting its then Presidential Aspirant, now President John Mahama, to call for urgent reforms.

The appointment of another member of the EC with known partisan affiliation also calls into question the role of the Council of State. In the unique case of the appointment of members of the Electoral Commission, the Constitution requires the President to appoint on the advice of the Council of State and not in consultation with. The Council of State’s consistent failure to develop any transparency process for the public to assess how it carries out its constitutional duties signals a breakdown in the current constitutional architecture.

CODEO’s concerns about Ms. Agbenyo’s appointment are not about her professional qualification or technical competence. Rather, it reflects a consistent principle of the Coalition that the independence and credibility of the Electoral Commission must be protected, and its leadership must inspire public confidence in its impartiality, regardless of which political party is in government. Unfortunately, the failure to mitigate these perceptions of bias by individual members of the Commission has severely affected citizen trust in the Commission, reaching its lowest ratings in 2024, according to the Afrobarometer.

The repeated failure to use the Presidential appointing power to reset the politics around the appointment of members to the Commission for the good of the country is extremely disappointing and frustrating. CODEO’s Call In March 2023, President John Dramani Mahama, while in opposition, criticised the appointment of persons he described as “known party activists” to the Electoral Commission and called for an amendment of Article 43(2) of the 1992 Constitution to require parliamentary approval of new Commissioners. He also affirmed his commitment to these reforms. CODEO considers this position relevant to the present circumstances.

The concerns President Mahama raised in opposition about partisan associations and the safeguards for the Electoral Commission’s independence are now directly relevant to appointments made under his own administration. The principles he advocated in 2023 must be applied consistently while in government. The credibility of electoral institutions demands that the same standards be upheld regardless of which political party holds power.

In view of the documented political engagement of Ms. Emelia Affi Agbenyo, CODEO:

1. Calls on Ms. Emelia Affi Agbenyo to honourably resign as Deputy Chairperson of the Electoral Commission in the interest of protecting public confidence in the Commission’s impartiality and institutional credibility.

2. Calls on President John Dramani Mahama to demonstrate consistency with his previously stated position by urging Ms. Agbenyo to resign. The President must demonstrate that the principles he advocated in opposition remain applicable under his own administration.

3. Calls on the Government to advance reforms that strengthen the independence of the Electoral Commission, ensuring that future appointments are transparent, meritbased and capable of commanding confidence across the political divide.

4. Calls on the Council of State to urgently take steps to develop processes for citizens to obtain information about how it discharges its national responsibility credibly, to engender trust amongst citizens. Conclusion and a Call for Reforming the Appointment Process CODEO reiterates its call for reforms to the appointment process for the leadership of the Electoral Commission. The Constitutional Review Committee (CRC) recommended an open, competitive and merit-based process involving a reformed Council of State, the Public Services Commission and prior parliamentary approval. However, the Government’s Position Paper rejected the proposed changes to the existing appointment arrangement, while indicating that the President could adopt transparent, merit-based procedures.

CODEO urges the Government to reconsider its position and pursue reforms that introduce independent scrutiny, transparent selection criteria and meaningful parliamentary oversight. Such safeguards would help address concerns about actual or perceived partisan influence before appointments are made, rather than after controversies arise. The concerns surrounding Ms. Agbenyo’s appointment underscore the urgency of these reforms. The independence of the Electoral Commission must be protected not only by constitutional provisions but also by a clear commitment of the political class to an independent and impartial electoral management body.