Analysts and strategists believe it may be too late for President Donald Trump to save his party from a midterm disaster, and that this year’s midterm results—whether they favor the GOP or not—are likely already “baked in.”
Trump is currently on a campaign-style tour of the United States, touting his achievements and agenda across Senate and House battlegrounds and urging voters to “close your eyes and pretend I’m on the ballot.” From the Oval Office, too, the administration is focused on addressing some of the electorate’s key concerns, such as its plan, met with opposition from Congress, to import Russian diesel to lower domestic prices.
But the party still trails Democrats in most forecasts for both chambers, and recent polling suggests there may be too little time to sway voters before November 3.
A Politico survey of 2,001 adults from October 3 to 5 found that most Americans would be no more likely to vote Republican even if Trump announced that the Iran war had ended, that he had created 100,000 new jobs, or if he were able to lower gas prices by $1 per gallon.
...
“I think the cake is baked, but for some major external event,” said Republican strategist Alex Patton, who told Newsweek he doubts the party can solve the Iran issue, rising fuel and food prices, or the president’s low approval ratings by Election Day.
“With three weeks to go, Republicans need something approaching a political miracle to turn this around,” said Brittany Martinez, a Republican strategist and executive director of the anti-Trump advocacy group Principles First. “Voters have lived with this administration’s decisions for months; one announcement won’t erase that experience or restore their trust.”
However, the White House remains confident that, with the president's backing, Republican candidates can exceed these currently bleak expectations in this year’s races.
“No one can dispute the fact that President Trump has created one of the most robust coalitions in political history with the MAGA movement, and the President understands how to communicate with them,” White House spokesman Davis Ingle told Newsweek. “President Trump is the unequivocal leader, best messenger, and unmatched motivator for the Republican Party, and he is committed to maintaining Republican majorities in Congress.”
Can Trump Do Anything to Save the GOP?
The latest polling averages from the aggregator Decision Desk HQ give Democrats a 49 percent to 41 percent lead over Republicans nationally. The forecaster Race to the WH gave Democrats an 88 percent chance of securing a House majority as of Thursday, and a 72 percent chance of winning the Senate.
According to Politico, just a small share of voters could be convinced to change their minds in the weeks leading up to the election.
Only 29 percent said that gas prices dropping by $1 from an average of $4.37 per gallon at the end of the polling period would make them more inclined to vote Republican. This figure slid to 28 percent when the question turned to Iran, with 20 percent even saying that an end to the war would make them less likely to vote Republican.
Other hypotheticals, such as a trade deal with China or inflation falling to a five-year low—a now-impossible scenario—had a comparably small effect on voting intentions, particularly among the crucial undecided group. Of those who said they were still unsure of their November 3 vote, only 16 percent said plummeting gas prices might push them closer to a Republican candidate, while just 17 percent were potentially swayed by the Iran war ending.
“This poll suggests Republicans have a problem that a single presidential announcement can’t solve,” George Hornedo, a political strategist and former Democratic candidate for Congress, told Newsweek.
“That’s a warning about the limits of presidential influence,” he told Newsweek. “The next three weeks still matter, but Republicans can’t assume that good news for the country will automatically become good news for their candidates.”
...
But Republican political consultant and strategist Matt Klink told Newsweek that “no political party seals a midterm victory three weeks out,” and described the Politico poll as “fundamentally flawed.”
“Pollsters asked adults to forecast their reaction to hypothetical news, and voters answer hypotheticals with their party ID,” he said. “Three in 10 Harris voters say they’d be ‘much less likely’ to vote Republican if Trump ended the war. Those aren’t swing voters. These are hardcore partisans.”
What Can Republicans Do?
Klink said Trump “can reduce losses if he delivers” on the issues outlined in the survey, though he notes not all of this responsibility will fall on the president.
“Republican candidates in races across the country need to pair relief on gas and food prices with a sharp contrast on taxes, the border, and crime, and spend the final three weeks on turnout.”
The party is spending significant sums on competitive races in 2026, funding ads that highlight the GOP candidates’ approaches to these issues and undermine the Democrats’ perceived failings. According to AdImpact figures shared with Newsweek, the GOP and its affiliates have spent about $1.6 billion on Senate ads this cycle, compared with $1.1 billion for Democrats.
And aside from messaging and ad spend—an endeavor with “diminishing returns” according to some—others have posited another option for Republicans hoping to maximize their odds.
"Over the last 3 weeks, you're going to see Republicans desperately trying to pretend they have distance from Donald Trump,” the Democratic strategist Jesse Ferguson told Newsweek. “The problem is, it doesn't do any good to turn the steering wheel on the Titanic after you already hit the iceberg."
A recent Newsweek investigation found that several Republican candidates in competitive races removed images of and references to Trump from their campaign websites, while emphasizing affordability issues and their plans to tackle the rising cost of living. A spokesperson for the Republican National Committee (RNC) accused Newsweek of “a lame attempt to manufacturer Republican collapse.”
...
“President Trump is still the unequivocal leader of the Republican Party. All year, President Trump has traveled around the country sharing the achievements of his administration with Republicans,” a White House official told Newsweek this week, noting that many candidates continue to attend events with and speak alongside the president.
The official also pointed to an Economist/YouGov poll conducted September 18 to 21 that showed Trump’s enjoyed approval ratings of 91 percent among MAGA voters, 75 percent among his 2024 voters and 79 percent among those who identify as Republicans. In a more recent survey from the same pollsters, these figures shifted slightly to 93 percent, an unchanged 75 percent and 77 percent, respectively.
How Republicans Could Pull off an Upset
While some have argued it would take a “political miracle” for Republicans to turn around their fortunes in the next few weeks, others believe recent election results mean the party could again exceed pundits’ and pollsters’ expectations.
As in 2016 and 2024, underrepresentation of Republican voters in polling is seen as something that could significantly limit their election forecasting potential and alter the results that are currently being penciled in. In certain races, such as Senator Susan Collins's bid for reelection in Maine, the Republican candidate has a proven track record of overcoming significant polling disadvantages before comfortably winning another term.
Pollster Chaz Nuttycombe, executive director of the election forecaster State Navigate, recently said a notable number of rural Republicans ignored their surveys, forcing the group to repeat certain polls. In a post on X, Nuttycombe called this a potential "Canary in the Cornfields for Iowa polling this year."
“While the political environment looks very negative for President Trump and Republicans right now, these are preelection polls and not votes,” Matt A. Barreto, faculty director at the UCLA Voting Rights Project, previously told Newsweek. “We don't yet know what voter turnout will be and Republicans do hold an advantage on fundraising and advertising spending.”
“As we start to see early vote and mail vote patterns, that will offer clues as to how mobilized and energized Democrats are, and whether Republicans are going to fight for Trump or stay home,” he said.
Want access to the latest insights on politics and economics? Sign up here to follow the money with Hugh Cameron and Newsweek’s Accountable Newsletter each week, from the fiscal debates dominating Washington to the real-world impact on your wallet.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Daniel Orton and Sam Wilson.