Spread the word
A skilled employee may face an odd choice: accept responsibility for managing people or remain at the same level indefinitely.
That is a narrow way to reward experience.
Organisations should create credible routes for people who become better at a craft without wanting to leave it. An excellent technician, editor or analyst does not necessarily become an excellent manager, and the wish to keep doing specialist work should not be mistaken for a lack of ambition.
The first requirement is a clear account of what advancement means. A more experienced specialist should be able to handle greater complexity, exercise sounder judgment or help improve standards. The role needs substance beyond a new title.
Assessment should examine that contribution. A manager’s progress may be visible through a team’s work. A specialist’s progress may appear in difficult problems resolved, reliable methods developed or errors prevented. The organisation should identify evidence appropriate to each path.
Pay matters. A specialist route that carries recognition but no meaningful improvement in compensation will struggle to compete with the management ladder. The structure should reflect the value of the work, rather than assume that supervising more people is the only form of greater responsibility.
The arrangement can also improve management appointments. Someone who genuinely wants to guide a team should not have to compete with every strong performer who sees no other way forward. A promotion should recognise the ability required for the new job.
Small organisations may have limited scope for formal grades. They can still discuss how a person’s responsibilities, pay and influence can develop without inventing a supervisory post the business does not need.
There are risks of creating an untouchable expert or rewarding seniority without improvement. Clear expectations and review remain necessary. Specialist standing should not exempt anyone from cooperation, learning or accountability.
Employees should also have room to change direction. A person may try management and decide that specialist work is a better fit. Returning should not automatically be treated as a demotion in personal worth.
Training can support both routes. Learning to manage is a separate undertaking, just as deepening a technical or creative practice is. Neither should be assumed to happen merely because someone has stayed long enough.
A business should want its best people to make an honest choice about where they can contribute. Offering only one ladder can push them into the wrong work or out of the organisation entirely.
Ambition includes becoming exceptionally good at something. A sensible promotion system should know how to recognise that.
Swaansh Mahat is an independent writer and English-language educator based in Kathmandu, Nepal
Spread the word