Next Monday, America Is Going to Be Watching Monday Night Football for One Reason. It’s Not Gonna Be the Game.

Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.

We have officially arrived at the dog days of the NFL season. Injuries have begun to ravage rosters into ineptitude. The weekly slate, reduced by schedule chicanery, is barren. Whole Sunday afternoons stretch out where a turgid Chargers/Cardinals affair is the only thing on TV. The optimism that bloomed in the collective spirit of fanbases in the spring and summer has already been derailed. The New York Jets are bad again. The Denver Broncos are unwatchable. The Miami Dolphins are in hell. There is very little to cling to as the weather gets colder, but thankfully, we’ve been rescued by a tantalizing flicker of media drama that will surely play out across the rest of the season. Apparently, one of the longest-tenured broadcasting partnerships on television is hurtling toward a bitter divorce, and I can’t wait to see what happens next.

Let’s back up for a second. For the better part of two decades, Joe Buck and Troy Aikman have been the marquee voices of the NFL. The two were paired by Fox back in 2002, and have been essentially married on television ever since. Buck, the son of legendary sportscaster Jack Buck, is the play-by-play guy—brandishing an understated decorum that lends an air of gravity to the on-field product. Troy Aikman won three Super Bowls with the Dallas Cowboys, and possesses a laconic sternness when analyzing football that doesn’t live up to his lofty standards. It was a match made in heaven. Buck and Aikman had instant chemistry together, and in 2022, ESPN hired them as the lead commentators for Monday Night Football—perhaps the most esteemed brand in American sports. The expectation was that the duo would ride off into the sunset together, in the same way John Madden and Pat Summerall made themselves immortal in the 1980s. But trouble was already brewing, and it’s just now coming to light.

Front Office Sports had the scoop. Basically, when ESPN poached Buck and Aikman, the two of them negotiated a contract paying out a combined $165 million over the course of five years. That contract is about to expire, and Buck has already settled on an extension—earning him another $100 million or so until 2033. (You might balk at the ludicrous amount of cash getting heaped on such a cushy job, but that’s the industry standard.) Aikman, meanwhile, has yet to re-up with ESPN, nor has the company offered him a new contract. This, according to the reporting, has caused real behind-the-scenes tension between the two men, to the point that they got into an “argument” last week, right before Buck and Aikman settled in for a Rams/Bills broadcast. The extent of the kerfuffle is unknown—Buck apparently characterized it as “breaking the ice”—but it conjures the image of Ron Burgundy and Veronica Corningstone sniping at each other right before a Channel 4 News broadcast. (There is precedent for this. In 1985 world-renowned Monday Night Football commentator Howard Cosell wrote a tell-all memoir where he roasted his on-air partners Don Meredith and Frank Gifford.) A few days after the story broke, Aikman addressed the rift on a Dallas radio station in a way that most certainly did not put the controversy to bed. Here’s Aikman:

“There’s probably a time and a place for all that. I don’t know if now is the time. I don’t know if it’s hard to figure out kind of what’s happened. I’ll broadcast through this season, and I’ll be a free agent at the end of the year and kind of see what happens.”

Ominous! It ought to be noted that we don’t really know exactly why Aikman has apparently reserved some of his animus for Buck, rather than ESPN’s upper management, considering they’re the ones who haven’t offered him a contract extension. (That certainly would rankle me.) InTouch Weekly has sources telling them it stems from Buck keeping his negotiations hidden from his partner, and that there is now “real hatred” between the two, when before they were like “brothers”—but as with most tabloids, I’d take that with a grain of salt. What all of this really means is that every football fan in America is now going to be hyperfixated on the Monday Night Football broadcast, desperate to decode the slightest twitches of angst between the two sportscasters. It’s already starting to happen. Two days ago, when Buck and Aikman welcomed us to a matchup between the San Francisco 49ers and the Washington Commanders, my Twitter algorithm billowed up with onlookers attempting to divine Aikman’s body language. (He “looks like he hates Joe Buck now,” wrote one.)

To be clear, the show went off without a hitch. These are professionals, and in all likelihood, the feud—if it is a feud—will not spill out onto national airwaves. But speaking as a man who loves me some good petty drama, I can’t wait for this story to unfold in the weeks ahead. Honestly, it outshines the actual football. Who cares if the Houston Texans can get back on track? Or if the Seattle Seahawks can fix their running game? The only thing I’m invested in is whether Buck and Aikman are able to hold it together publicly while a bone-deep resentment allegedly burbles in the background. Could we get a full-blown fight before December? Will Aikman put his partner in a chokehold? Frankly, we should be able to bet on this on FanDuel.

The best part? ESPN is broadcasting the Super Bowl this year. That means Aikman and Buck will be hosting what might be their final game together with the whole sports universe watching. Screw Jay-Z—that’ll be the real halftime show.