Memphis officials are weighing whether to temporarily halt new data center development Tuesday as a battle over the rapidly expanding industry, including Elon Musk's massive artificial intelligence operation, reaches a pivotal vote.
The Memphis City Council is considering a proposed yearlong moratorium on new data centers and expansions of existing facilities, two weeks after its previous meeting descended into shouting, protests, and a fight outside the council chamber.
The Oct. 6 meeting descended into chaos after council members voted 7-5 to postpone action on the moratorium, with protesters chanting as police cleared the chamber. Two women later fought in the City Hall lobby, according to WMC-TV, which reported that police said no one was injured or detained.
Tuesday's debate is broader than a single up-or-down vote. Council members are expected to consider six data-center-related items, including the original moratorium and competing proposals addressing how Memphis should regulate the facilities. Several of the proposals cannot coexist in their current forms, leaving uncertainty over what ultimately emerges from the meeting.
The confrontation comes as cities across the country wrestle with the enormous energy, water, and infrastructure demands created by the race to build the computing capacity needed for artificial intelligence.
Elon Musk's Memphis Expansion
At the center of the Memphis debate is Musk's SpaceXAI operation and the Colossus supercomputing facilities that have helped transform the city into a flashpoint in the national dispute over AI infrastructure.
Musk's AI company began converting a former industrial facility in southwest Memphis into its Colossus supercomputer operation in 2024. Musk described Colossus at the time as the "most powerful AI training system in the world."
But the development has faced persistent opposition from some nearby residents, who have raised concerns about air quality, water and energy use, and noise.
Those concerns intensified over the company's use of gas-powered turbines. The NAACP filed a federal Clean Air Act lawsuit this year over turbines at the company's Southaven, Mississippi, operation, while the Justice Department subsequently urged a court to dismiss the case. The litigation remains active, according to CNN.
...
Council member JB Smiley Jr., who sponsored the proposed moratorium, said the measure would provide the city time to establish safeguards rather than permanently shut the door on data centers.
"We're not saying no to data centers forever; we're saying slow it down so that we can make the necessary adjustments so that we can protect neighborhoods and property value, so we can make sure there's not a detrimental impact on the environment," Smiley told CNN on Tuesday.
"We have to make sure we're putting people before profits."
If approved as described, the moratorium would temporarily stop new data center developments and expansions while a committee develops regulations. Existing facilities operating legally in Memphis would not be shut down.
Memphis Mayor Paul Young has separately ordered a 90-day review aimed at developing recommendations for regulating large-scale data centers. His office said that process would run concurrently with the council's deliberations and would not prevent the council from taking action.
City Hall Fight Escalates
The intensity of the dispute erupted publicly at the Oct. 6 council meeting.
After council members voted 7-5 to postpone action on the moratorium, protesters chanted as police moved to clear the chamber. A fight between two women later broke out in the City Hall lobby, according to Action News 5. A Memphis Police Department spokesperson told the outlet that no one was detained or injured.
Councilwoman Yolanda Cooper-Sutton also clashed with members of the crowd and criticized Smiley during the contentious session.
Meanwhile, crowds had begun lining up outside City Hall ahead of Tuesday's meeting, according to WREG-TV's reporting supplied for this story.
The council's eventual decision could determine not only whether Memphis pauses further data center growth, but what regulatory framework one of the country's most closely watched AI infrastructure hubs puts in place.
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here. Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Edward T. Cummins