Invest in FDs: Harsh Goenka's advice to Tata Sons

Listen to this article in summarized format

At a time when Indian stock market is declining, Industrialist Harsh Goenka has floated a hypothetical idea involving Tata Sons' massive listed equity portfolio, pointing to the amount of money it could generate if invested in fixed deposits or other relatively safe instruments. In a post on X, Goenka said Tata Sons' listed equity portfolio, valued at around ₹11.68 lakh crore, could potentially generate annual income of ₹70,000 crore to ₹82,000 crore if the money were invested in instruments yielding 6% to 7%.

He compared this potential income with the annual dividend of around ₹4,475 crore that Tata Sons currently receives, suggesting that the returns from such an investment could be made available for philanthropy and social good. However, Goenka made it clear that he was not recommending that Tata Sons sell its equity holdings. He described the idea as a hypothetical thought worth considering.

What did Harsh Goenka say about Tata Sons?

"Just a thought experiment: Tata Sons pays a dividend of around ₹4,475 crore a year. Suppose its ₹11.68 lakh crore listed equity portfolio were sold and invested in safe instruments yielding 6–7%, it could generate an annual income of ₹70,000–82,000 cr, potentially all available for philanthropy and social good. I am certainly not suggesting this. Just a hypothetical thought worth pondering," Harsh Goenka posted on X.

How much could ₹11.68 lakh crore generate in fixed deposits?

The numbers in Goenka's post are based on applying an annual return of 6% to 7% to a portfolio worth ₹11.68 lakh crore. At a 6% annual return, the investment would generate approximately ₹70,080 crore a year. At 7%, the annual income would rise to around ₹81,760 crore.

These figures are mathematical estimates, not guaranteed returns. Actual income would depend on the instruments chosen, prevailing interest rates, applicable taxes and other investment conditions. The comparison also assumes that the entire portfolio could be converted into cash and reinvested at the stated rates. In practice, selling a portfolio of this size could have significant financial and tax implications.

Why the comparison is significant

The idea highlights the difference between dividend income from shares and interest income from fixed-income investments. Companies pay dividends when their boards approve distributions from available profits. Dividend income can fluctuate depending on business performance, earnings and corporate decisions. Fixed deposits, meanwhile, generally offer a predetermined interest rate for a specified period, subject to the terms of the deposit and the financial institution.

However, the two are not directly interchangeable. Listed equity holdings can appreciate over time and provide exposure to the growth of businesses. Selling them could mean giving up future capital appreciation, voting rights and other strategic benefits associated with share ownership. A large portfolio may also serve purposes beyond generating dividend income. Its investments could reflect long-term ownership interests and the broader objectives of the group.

Tata Sons' role extends beyond dividend income

Tata Sons is the principal holding company of the Tata Group, whose businesses operate across sectors including automobiles, information technology, steel, consumer products and aviation. Its investments in listed companies represent ownership interests in businesses that may generate returns through dividends as well as changes in share prices. Assessing their value solely through annual dividend receipts would therefore leave out other important considerations.

Goenka's hypothetical scenario instead raises a broader question about the use of capital: how much income could a large investment pool generate if its primary objective were to produce relatively predictable returns for social causes? The answer depends on the assumptions used. An investment yielding 6% to 7% could produce substantial annual cash flows, but the choice between equity ownership and fixed-income investments involves trade-offs in growth, risk, liquidity and long-term value.

Read More News on